A US restaurant had its logo designed by AI and faced a wave of one-star reviews once customers found out. New research shows a majority of consumers trust a brand less when it visibly leans on AI. What does that mean for your own logo or rebrand?
Run a logo brief through an AI tool and within minutes you have three usable proposals, almost free. For anyone who needs a mark quickly, that feels like a good deal. A restaurant in Santa Cruz showed this spring that the deal can end up costing more than a designer's invoice.
The owner had a logo generated with AI and refined the result herself. Once it became known how the mark had been made, the restaurant faced a wave of one-star reviews. Not about the food, about the logo. She took the mark down and replaced it with a simple black-and-white text wordmark showing just the restaurant's name.
Designers disagree on the quality of AI-generated logos. Some consider them usable for a quick first direction, others point out marks that look suspiciously close to existing brands, with all the legal risk that carries. The backlash in Santa Cruz, though, was not about a technical flaw in the design. Customers felt misled about who, or what, had actually created the brand. That feeling outweighed the end result itself.
That reaction is not an isolated case. A US research firm surveyed more than six hundred consumers last summer and found that more than half are less likely to buy from a brand that uses AI in its social content, and that two in three trust a brand less once AI turns out to have misrepresented a product. A separate survey of US consumers found that six in ten see the word AI in brand messaging as a turnoff, and that a clear majority don't fully trust AI-generated content at all.
Even so, the picture is more nuanced than plain AI aversion. Research into brand authenticity shows consumers mind AI use less once a brand is open about it, and actually trust a brand more when a human reviews and guides the AI output. The problem is not AI itself, but AI posing as the sole, invisible mind behind a brand.
The difference lies in where AI sits in the process. As a tool for a moodboard, colour exploration or a first sketch, AI saves a designer time without handing over the final decisions. As a replacement for the whole design process, from brief to finished mark, it misses exactly the part customers apparently value: a person who makes deliberate choices, tests them, and can explain why something works.
That difference is also practical. An AI-generated image is a picture, not a brand system. A logo has to work on a shopfront, an invoice, a social avatar and a signed email, in black and white and in colour, large and tiny. It has to be distinctive enough not to accidentally resemble an existing mark. That calls for someone who tests the result, adjusts it, and documents it in a style guide, not the first image a generator hands back.
Design studios looking ahead to the coming years see a shift back towards texture, hand-drawn detail and a visibly human creative process, as a counterweight to the smooth, interchangeable look every generator delivers by default. That fits what the research already shows: customers notice and value traces of human work, even when they can't quite name why.
Part of that same brand authenticity research also reveals the flip side: a clear majority of the consumers surveyed simply want to know when AI was involved in content or a design. Not to reject it outright, but to judge for themselves how much weight to give it. A brand that is open about this scores better in those same studies than a brand that stays quiet and hopes nobody asks.
AI does have a place in a good design process, just not at the end of it. Use it for the exploration phase: laying dozens of directions side by side quickly, testing a colour palette, getting a first feel for a style before a cent is spent on actual design work. Then leave the selection, refinement and final execution to a designer who can defend the result, adapt it across applications, and have it checked for distinctiveness against existing brands.
Document which steps in the process used AI and which didn't, so you can answer that question when a customer, journalist or reviewer asks it. A few lines of documentation cost little time and prevent exactly the scenario the Santa Cruz restaurant ran into: not a weak design, but a story that didn't hold up the moment someone pushed back.
Use AI to get to a first direction faster if you like, but leave the final choice and execution to someone who takes responsibility for the result, including checking that your design doesn't accidentally resemble an existing brand. Be open about where AI helped in your process, and it tends to work in your favour rather than against you. Hide it, and you risk someone finding out anyway, at a point you can no longer explain it yourself.
Wondering whether your current logo or visual identity still holds up, or considering a new mark and want to be sure the process is sound? Zarioh helps think through branding and design that fits your organisation, with a clear eye for what AI does well and where it doesn't. Feel free to get in touch for a no-obligation conversation.
Zarioh Digital Solutions
IT specialists from Utrecht, the Netherlands. We help businesses with Microsoft 365, AI agents, hosting and telephony, and share what we learn in practice. Follow us on LinkedIn

Branding & Design

Branding & Design

Branding & Design